What I have to talk about today is a little delicate. No one likes to talk about something where they didn’t do as good as they could have. But the important thing isn’t always what you do but how you handle it. I think this is a case where we have rebounded well.
As you may know, Standard Publishing is one of the top 5 publishers of Vacation Bible Study materials. In fact, we were the first company to use the term, way back in 1922. I wish we had gotten it copyrighted or patented or whatever. But we didn’t. So we slog it out every year.
The big challenge for all of us each year is coming up with a new theme that is creative, entertaining, educational but true to the Bible. Historically, Standard has competed in the niche of being safe and true to the Bible, but not always the “glitziest” thing out there. In 2009, we came out with a theme of Studio GO! It was based on a television game show. It had the Bob Barker host and the crazy contestants. It was highly entertaining. In fact, it was probably the most entertaining program we have ever done (I must confess that I haven’t seen all 87 of them!). It was still very much rooted in the Bible, but it wasn’t clear that that was the case.
As we look back on our testing (focus groups, one on ones, Survey Monkey, you name it, we did it), hindsight tells us that we should have been concerned. While it got high marks for interest and “intent to use”, it also got high than normal marks for “no intent to use”. In market research, you call that “polarization”. Think of Sarah Palin. In popularity polls, she scores very high on likeability. But she also scores very high on dislikeability. When you roll out a product, you need to get some of the “fence sitters” to say, “OK, I’ll go with the Standard product”. But if you have strong negative feelings, the fence sitters go with the safer product from our competition.
So we got many of our loyal churches. But we lost some of the more conservative churches. They said, “Do we really want to be teaching our kids that watching tv game shows is a good idea?” Bottom-line, we lost some share to our competitors.
But the good news is that you start off anew every year. Keep making mistakes and you will find yourself in trouble. But the marketplace will bounce back from one bad year. Needless to say, we entered the VBS race with some trepidation. We were very careful in our research. We wanted a theme that would be exciting but perceived as “safe” and true to the Bible.
Our new theme is Hero Headquarters. It’s really a very creative theme. Think about it. There are three kinds of heroes. First are the superheroes like the ones in the comics. We didn’t want to go with the “Hollywood” ones or we would have another “glitz” problem. So we invented our own such as Water Woman and Maintenance Man. Then there are the “everyday” heroes such as policemen, firemen, teachers and parents. So we added that element. Finally, you have the Biblical heroes. But we added a great twist there. As we prepared a list of Biblical heroes, it dawned on us that, for many, we don’t know their names. There were unnamed heroes. So for our daily stories, we highlighted five unnamed heroes such as the little boy who brought the loaves and fishes. What this says to kids is that you don’t have to be a big celebrity to be a hero. We can all be heroes for the Lord!
So how are we doing? So far, so good. Our presales numbers are up versus last year. At our first big trade show, the Children’s Pastors Conference, we sold $5,000 more kits than last year. I’ll keep you informed, but I believe the train is back on the track!